Cauldron of Ghosts – Snippet 04

Cauldron of Ghosts – Snippet 04

Chapter 5

“I’d miss Steph,” Andrew Artlett protested. “Just for starters. Then there’s the lousy pay.”

Princess Ruth Winton frowned. “Lousy pay? You’re being offered almost half again what you’re making here on Torch — and you’re getting top rate for starship mechanics.” After a brief pause — very brief; Ruth hated admitting to a lack of complete expertise on any subject — she added: “So I’m told, anyway.”

“Well, yeah. But going back to Parmley Station to work on this project is risky as all hell.” Stoutly: “I should be getting hazard pay. That’s generally figured as a hundred percent pay increase. Double-time, that is.”

There were so many fallacies and lapses of logic in those statements that the Manticoran princess was rendered almost speechless.

Almost. Speechlessness was a state of affairs that was probably impossible for Ruth Winton.

What? That’s insane! Every single sentence you just said is blithering nonsense.”

She began counting off her fingers. “First off, there’s nothing at all risky for you in this deal. Your aunt Elfride, maybe –”

“Don’t call her that to her face,” Andrew cautioned. “She answers to Ganny. Or Ganny El, if she likes you.”

“I have met the woman. I was just being formal. Seeing as how this is supposed to be an employment interview.” Ruth looked simultaneously cross and a bit embarrassed. “Of sorts,” she added.

“‘Employment interview’!” Artlett said mockingly. “Oh, yeah. I can see it in the want ads now.” He mimicked holding up a reading tablet. “‘Wanted. Damn fool mechanic for desperado duties aiding and abetting Audubon Ballroom sociopaths –”

He glanced at the huge figure of Hugh Arai, who was lounging in a nearby armchair in the princess’ suite. (Ruth called it a working office, but that was the obliviousness to luxury of someone born and raised in Mount Royal Palace in Manticore’s capital city of Landing. It was a no-fooling suite, on the top floor of the finest hotel in Beacon.)

“Meaning no offense, Hugh, I’m just saying it like it is.” Arai smiled at him.

Andrew resumed pretending to read a want ad: “– and Beowulfan cold-blooded killers masquerading as biologists — ”

Again he glanced at Arai. “Meaning no offense. Just telling it like it is.” The smile became a grin.

Back to the imaginary want ad: ” — for the purpose of hunting down any and all practitioners of the slave trade, which individuals are noted — no, notorious — throughout the inhabited portions of the galaxy for their cruelty and depraved indifference to human life, including that of starship mechanics.”

Triumphantly, he set down the imaginary tablet. “Ha!”

Ruth had waited for him to finish. Impatiently, because she was impatient with silliness by nature. But she’d still waited. She knew Artlett well enough by now to know there was no point in trying to derail him when he was hell-bent on riding his broad (broad? say better, oceanically expansive) sense of humor to the end of the track.

“If we might return to reality for a moment,” she said, “your duties will keep you on Parmley Station most of the time. A construct that is not only one of the largest space-going installations within light years of its solar system but is by now almost as heavily armed as an orbital fortress.”

Hugh shook his head. “Bit of an exaggeration, Ruth. The defenses and armaments on Parmley Station aren’t designed to fight off a battle fleet.”

Andrew started to say something, probably along the lines of claiming that Arai was supporting him, but Hugh’s deep voice rode over him easily. “But they’ll squash any pirates or slavers who show up as easily as swatting an insect.”

He gave Artlett a beady gaze: “As you know perfectly well, since you were paid to be a consultant when we designed those defenses.”

“Still.” Andrew was nothing if not stubborn. He waved his hand in a gesture that might mean… pretty much anything. “Pirates. Slavers. Dangerous people, no matter how you slice it.”

He decided to fall back onto more sensible grounds. “And like I said, I’d miss Steph.”

Ruth pounced. “Why is that? I just talked to her this morning and she seemed quite amenable to relocating to Parmley Station.”

Andrew stared at her. “She… But — she told me — it was just a few weeks ago!”

Ruth waved her hand airily. “That was then, this is now. She’s had time since to gauge the real possibilities at either place. Here, on Torch, it seems like everybody and their grandmother is setting up a restaurant. The competition is brutal. The hours, long; the income…” The princess made a face, as if she had any idea of the harsh realities of trying to run a small restaurant.

Which, of course, she didn’t. But Ruth Winton never let petty details like her own ignorance get in the way of a good argument. She pressed on.

“Whereas on Parmley Station — ” The royal expression became positively beatific, as she contemplated the commercial advantages of opening a restaurant there.

“It’s a busted enterprise,” jeered Artlett. “A pipe dream on the part of my great-uncle Michael Parmley — a screwball if there ever was one — who poured a fortune into building the galaxy’s most derelict orbital amusement park.”

“That was then, this is now,” interjected Hugh Arai. “As you know perfectly well, Andrew.” He leaned forward. “Today, it’s on the verge of becoming Beowulf’s central hub for covert operations against Mesa and Manpower.”

“The best clientele you could ask for!” Ruth said enthusiastically. “Beefy commando types. They eat like horses and tip like the upper crust.”

Most of that was pretty accurate. Not all covert operations people were beefy; but they did tend to eat a lot. That was a combination of a usually high-powered metabolism with near-constant physical training.

The analogy to the tipping habits of upper crust gamblers was wide of the mark, though. Wealthy people actually tended to be on the cheapskate side when it came to things like tipping. And charity, for that matter. It had been a constant for millennia that people of average means gave a higher percentage of their income to charitable causes than rich people — especially when you factored into the equation the end beneficiaries. Average people gave to those poorer than they. Rich people usually donated their money to cultural institutions — museums, universities and opera houses, for instance — of which they or their children were major personal beneficiaries. And then named them after themselves.

There were exceptions, of course, and those individuals could be spectacular in their largesse. The Winton dynasty had a long tradition of being very generous, especially for medical causes. Ruth’s misapprehension was the understandable product of her own personal experience.

But while the analogy was off, the reality remained. Covert ops people did tend to tip generously — and Andrew knew it, from having spent a lot of time in their company over the past period.

He ran fingers through his hair, in a gesture of exasperation. “Damn it, she was the one who insisted on coming here in the first place. I would have been perfectly happy to stay on Parmley Station. Women!”

Ruth had her own opinion — well-formed; cured; tempered; hardened; sharp on all edges and corners — as to which of the two human genders was actually prone to flightiness, inconstancy and indecision. Shakespeare’s greatest play wasn’t about a princess of Denmark, now was it?

But she saw no reason to squabble over the matter, since Artlett was now clearly on the verge of capitulating to logic and reason.

“All right, then,” he said. “I’ll go. If it’s okay with Steph.”


After Andrew left the suite, Hugh cleared his throat. “I noticed that you left out some particulars.”

“I wouldn’t call them ‘particulars.’ Speculative possibilities is closer to the mark.”

Arai shook his head. “You’re quibbling and you know it. What you’re calling ‘speculative possibilities’ are part of the established plans for using the Hali Sowle.

“Established by whom?” Ruth countered. “Ganny El still hasn’t agreed — and if she doesn’t, the whole deal collapses.”

“I know you didn’t learn to lie, cheat and steal at Mount Royal Palace. So where does it come from, this brazen shamelessness? This cunning deftness at misdirection and maneuver? This dazzling expertise at deceit and deception?”

“You might be surprised at what goes on in the corridors and back rooms of Mount Royal Palace, Hugh. But, no, I didn’t learn the skills there. No more than the rudiments, anyway.”

She sniffed. “Where do you think? I’ve been studying for the past three years at Zilwicki and Cachat University.”

Hugh chuckled. “Point. Speaking of which, do you think they’re really responsible for the slaughter on Mesa?”

“I assume you’re referring to the claim being spread by Manpower through the Solarian media that they set off the nuclear explosion at Green Pines. If so, the answer is ‘no.’ It’s clear they didn’t do it. We’ll get the full story from them when they arrive here.”

Word had come from Sharon Justice, one of Haven’s representatives on Erewhon, that Zilwicki and Cachat had arrived at Parmley Station a few weeks earlier. But her message had contained no other information beyond the bare fact that they were alive.

Arai leaned back in his chair and clasped his fingers over his belly. “Explain your reasoning.” His tone wasn’t argumentative, just interested.

“Hell, Hugh, it’s obvious.” She leaned forward in her own chair, sliding almost to the edge of it. Ruth was not capable of thinking or expounding anything in a relaxed position. Within less than a minute, Hugh knew from experience, she’d have risen from the chair and started pacing.

“For starters, if they were going to set off that large an explosion, why pick that target?”

“Well, according to the news reports –”

“Oh, please!” Ruth got to her feet. Hugh glanced at his watch. Seven seconds.

“That silly business about Green Pines being a residential center for the Mesan elite? Every other apartment in the complex inhabited by a Manpower big shot? That’s why it was targeted?”

By the time she finished, she’d taken five steps one way and was now reversing direction. Long steps, too; Ruth was a strider.


This entry was posted in Snippets, WeberSnippet. Bookmark the permalink.
Skip to top


18 Responses to Cauldron of Ghosts – Snippet 04

  1. John Roth says:

    More scene setting. Padded unmercifully. At least it’s introducing bits that will be important later.

  2. Ncwolf says:

    I don’t know about padding (albeit tvtropes says RFC has “editorial immunity”); I kinda like Andrew A., although I did have him confused with his younger relative Brice for a bit there, but that’s just me.

  3. Robert A. Woodward says:

    Just a second now: “Word had come from Sharon Justice, one of Haven’s representatives on Erewhon, that Zilwicki and Cachat had arrived at Parmley Station a few weeks earlier” – Andrew Artlett and Steph arrived at Parmley Station on the same ship (which he had repaired in flight). Why would Ruth need word from Erewhon? The news was standing right in front of her.

  4. Mike says:

    I know these are drafts posted here, but there are some minor continuity errors popping up. Either the timelines changed and didn’t get fixed in this draft, or this business of running several books with multiple authors through the same material from different points of view is too complicated to manage correctly.

    Andrew and Steff just spent months on a small boat with Cachat and Zilwicki. They must know what happened.

  5. John Roth says:

    Well, I wouldn’t call it a continuity error as much as an exposition and editing issue: word had come in via Sharon Justice – she’d have distributed it in a number of places where Andrew Arlet wasn’t present. The actual continuity error is the surprise on Haven when Zilwiki and Cachet arrive. Unless they beat the official word percolating through intelligence channels.

    The “explanation,” I won’t call it an excuse, is that CoG was almost done a couple of years ago when DW was musing whether to release it or Shadow of Freedom first. Then Eric’s mid 2012 “things in progress” page said he was still working on it, and he was working on it again this last summer, and there were still things being worked on at Honorcon. I can’t say I’m surprised that it shows signs of being worked over hastily.

  6. Stephen says:

    There seem to be three possible readings:

    1) this is a reference to their making back to Parmley Station from Mesa, in which case Artlet is a clearly superior source for the fact that they’re alive, and that sentence should just die. That puts this snippet way out of time, though, because clearly some time has passed since Artlet and Steph got to Torch.

    This would be a big continuity error. Might there be smaller errors possible?

    If this snippet is set later in time….

    2) Maybe the error is in the term “Parmley Station,” and the message reported that they’d made it to Haven or Manticore in one piece

    Or 3) Maybe they’re on their way back to Parmley Station from Manticore.

    Ruth and Arai might have any number of reasons for not discussing issues like bombs with Artlet and Steph, given how easily compartmentalization comes to the espionage business.

    Of course, the problem with any and all of these intepretations is that Ruth and Arai should have speculated the heck out of the Green Pine rumors when they first heard them, BEFORE the crew got back to anywhere from Mesa, and thus before even the earliest possible placement of this snippet, thus making it a very awkwardly chosen point to insert this bit of exposition even under the most charitable reading.

    Hopefully they’ll change that in editing.

    • Cobbler says:

      Ruth and Arai might have any number of reasons for not discussing issues like bombs with Artlet and Steph, given how easily compartmentalization comes to the espionage business.

      Am I missing something here? Isn’t the espionage business sort of the information business? Compartmentalization isn’t supposed to prevent you from learning things. If you ask someone “What actually happened”, the only information you are giving out is your ignorance.

      It seems to me an advantage if intelligence agents seem ignorant. Preferably more ignorant than they really are, but still…

      • Stephen says:

        At the very least they might have any number of reasons for not considering Steph and Artlet to be decisive sources. What you need for a remotely charitable reading is some answer to the question “why don’t they just ask the people who were there and who are obviously present?”

        I would personally wager that the second part of this snippet was originally written for a different scene and got transplanted here through some careless revision.

        • Cobbler says:

          There are two classes of stupid to my writing:

          I wrote stupid.

          I edited stupid.

          The charitable explanation here is, someone edited stupid.

  7. Terranovan says:

    What Weber & Flint have to say about the wealthy & tipping matches with what I’ve read about the patterns of tipping on the Internet (can’t remember where, exactly, but I think might be a good place to start).
    Also, Captain Sharon Justice figured semi-prominently in the Eric Flint short story “Fanatic” (about Cachat shortly before, during, & shortly after the Theisman coup – she was StateSec “Citizen Captain Justice” then).

    • Terranovan says:

      Oops – I meant to put in as a hyperlink just after “but I think”. All of the words after should’ve been plaintext.

      • Mike says:

        It is *so* nice to go to Europe where staff is actually paid by the restaurant and tips essentially don’t exist. This is one of those references you sometimes see in SF that make me chuckle. Of all the many customs that could survive for thousands of years into the future, why would tipping at restaurants be one of them? Most of the world doesn’t even do it now.

        • Chris says:

          Even in Europe tipping does happen often, just nothing like in the USA. Normally, you tip in mid-range and above restaurants and that’s about it (also the percentages are much less).

          I have no doubt that tipping in the European sense of small sums to express gratitude, or larger sums for exceptional service, will make it to the stars.

  8. “Ruth hated admitting to a lack of complete expertise on any subject ”

    Good to see we have a seriously flawed character who can in the fullness of time receive an authorial education.

    • John Roth says:

      She comes by it legitimately, from both parents. She is, after all, Masadan, not Manticoran and not a member of the Royal Family by blood. Only by adoption. Her predilection for taking wildly wrong guesses has been pointed out in previous books, but more with a scalpel. This is bludgeon quality writing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *